7 | DAILY DOSE OF 32-0 | THE RAFFY TULFO IN ACTION VS. ATTY. LIBAYAN COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT CASE
00:58.5
Pag kinasuhan sila ng Rafi Tulfo in action o kahit sino man na mga mag-aastang Rafi Tulfo in action in the future,
01:06.2
yung mga umiiyak tapos sasabihin na copyright infringement tapos madi-dismiss lang.
01:14.2
Okay? Ngayon mga kabatas natin, let's start.
01:18.9
Sabi niya dito mga kabatas natin,
01:20.3
Indeed, the issue here is whether or not the proper time,
01:24.1
i.e. rights of the copyright owner shall prevail over the right of the accused to freedom of expression
01:30.3
or the right of the press to freedom of speech.
01:35.4
Alam niyo mga kabatas natin, may nakausap akong abogado tungkol dito.
01:38.9
Sa korte din, no?
01:40.8
Kasi nga, binanggit ko yung freedom of expression at freedom of speech.
01:49.2
Paano ba? Ang nangyari, sabi ganyan sa akin,
01:54.1
Well, ang nangyari dun sa party, sabi niya ganyan,
01:58.6
wala bang pagkakataon para magkaayos, parang gano'n.
02:03.3
Parang ang mangyari, itigil mo na lang yung ginagawa mo, parang gano'n.
02:08.2
Sinabi ko, sinabi nung kabila,
02:11.0
Ba't ako? Nasira tuloy yung kwento.
02:14.6
Anyway, hindi niyo naman alam kung sino yung kausap ko.
02:17.6
Sinabi ko, hindi pwede.
02:18.8
Sabi ko ganyan sa kanya.
02:20.8
Hindi pwede na, na,
02:22.7
na isa sa mga dahilan para maareglo itong kasong ito,
02:27.4
ay tumigil ako sa ginagawa ko.
02:31.5
Hypothetical na lang ito, mga kapatid natin.
02:34.8
Ako na lang, but this is hypothetical.
02:37.2
Okay? Hypothetical.
02:39.5
Sabi ganyan, mga kapatid natin,
02:40.9
sabi ko, hindi pwede.
02:42.1
Hindi pwede na itigil ko.
02:44.4
Kasi kapag kunwari, tinigil ko ito,
02:47.8
maapektuhan, sabi kong ganyan,
02:49.9
yung aking freedom of speech,
02:51.5
freedom of expression, at siyempre,
02:53.5
because I'm also a public personality,
02:56.5
it is not good doon sa...
02:59.5
Hypothetical lang ito, ha?
03:01.5
Hindi ito tunay na nangyari.
03:03.5
Hindi ito tunay na nangyari, mga kapatid natin.
03:06.5
Sabi ko, hindi ito maganda doon sa mga tao na magiging example.
03:13.5
Kunwari ako lang, kunwari ako lang.
03:17.5
Hypothetical lang ito.
03:19.5
Hypothetical lang ito. Hindi pwede.
03:21.2
Hindi pwede, sabi ko.
03:22.2
I cannot, I cannot stop.
03:24.2
Sabi ko, I'm not doing anything wrong.
03:28.2
Tapos sinabi nung kabila, sabi niyang ganyan,
03:31.2
bakit naman ang usapan ay copyright infringement?
03:36.2
Ay sorry, bakit ang usapan ay freedom of speech and expression
03:41.2
samantalang ang kaso naman ay copyright infringement?
03:45.2
Immaterial naman yung sinasabi mo, sabi sa akin.
03:48.2
Sabi ko, material yun.
03:52.2
Alam mo kung bakit?
03:53.2
Kasi nga, pinapatigil niyo ako doon sa ginagawa ko.
03:59.2
Yun naman ang punto ko doon.
04:02.2
So, saan ang copyright infringement doon?
04:05.2
Sabi niyang ganyan, wala.
04:06.2
Pero kayo, pinapatigil niyo ako.
04:08.2
Nasaan doon yung pagbawal sa aking freedom of expression at saka freedom of speech?
04:14.2
Yung pagpapatigil niyo sa akin.
04:17.2
Kasi ang nangyari na,
04:19.2
kundisyon para iatras yung kaso, tumigil ka na.
04:24.2
Di ba? Pero hypothetical lang yun. Hindi tunay na nangyari yun. Okay?
04:29.2
Hindi tunay na nangyari yun.
04:31.2
Sabi niya, irrelevant naman yung depensa mo.
04:34.2
Ano hindi niya nga ako nagdidepensa dito?
04:37.2
Kala ko ba pag-aayos yung pinag-uusapan?
04:40.2
Hindi lang talaga ako pwedeng, sabi niya, hindi pwedeng depensa ang freedom of speech at saka freedom of expression
04:47.2
sa copyright infringement.
04:49.2
Sabi ko, anong hindi pwedeng depensa?
04:51.2
Anong depensa ang sinasabi mo?
04:53.2
Ang pinag-uusapan natin dito?
04:56.2
E, ang areglo, gusto niyo akong patigilin.
04:59.2
E di syempre, maapektuhan yung aking freedom of expression at saka freedom of speech.
05:07.2
Parang ito rin, sinabi niya.
05:09.2
Naisip ko lang na ano, hindi naalala, naisip ko lang yung senaryo na yun.
05:15.2
Hindi tunay na nangyari yun.
05:17.2
Naisip ko lang kasi nung linabas nung judge nga ito.
05:28.2
Sabi niya, itago natin sa pangalang Atty. 30, hindi tunay na pangalan.
05:32.2
Yung kausap, itago natin sa pangalang Atty. 320, hindi tunay na nangyari.
05:36.2
Tsaka hindi tunay na nangyari yun.
05:38.2
Kasi naisip ko lang, hindi ko naalala, nadulas na nun yun.
05:43.2
Naisip ko lang dahil dito.
05:45.2
Sabi ko, bakit ako titigil?
05:48.2
Sabi ko, eh wala na. Ano na sa freedom of expression ko dyan saka freedom of speech ko.
05:58.2
Hindi na angkop yun sa aking kalayaan, sabi ko.
06:02.2
Tapos sabi nila, copyright infringement naman itong kasong ito.
06:06.2
Bakit anong freedom of expression saka freedom of speech ang sinasabi mo?
06:11.2
Pinapatigil niyo ako eh.
06:18.2
For strange as it is, it is the lawyer accused as commenter to a legal public service program of a journalist who is in the position of a journalist herein.
06:31.2
Sabi ng judge dito mga kabatas natin, it's very strange.
06:35.2
It's very strange na parang ako daw na abogado,
06:42.2
na nagko-comment, ako pa yung nasa posisyon ng isang journalist.
06:52.2
Tapos sabi, the journalist by doing the public service program delving on the legal system opens himself up to public criticism by anyone and most certainly by rights as officers of the court lawyers.
07:08.2
Tignan nyo mga kabatas natin, no. Ang sinabi nila, by rights.
07:11.2
Bilang isang karapatan.
07:18.2
Kasi officer of the court ako eh.
07:21.2
Tulad nga na sinabi ko sa inyo, ang unang-una na naaalala ko talaga na na bad trip ako sa Rafi Tulfo.
07:28.2
Bad trip na ako dun sa pagpapalabas nila.
07:30.2
Speaking of bad trip, no.
07:34.2
Speaking of bad trip.
07:36.2
Speaking of bad trip, ha.
07:38.2
Ang unang-unang na bad trip.
07:40.2
Ang unang-unang na bad trip ako sa Rafi Tulfo in action, aside from the fact na yung pinagkakakitaan nila, yung mga misfortune ng tao, ay yung itong si Rafi Tulfo, makailang beses, no.
07:57.2
Makailang beses na sabi nang sabi sa mga nag-aaway na mag-asawa sa kanyang programa na kapag 7 years old na yung bata, pwede nang mamili yung bata.
08:09.2
So kahit hindi kasal yung mag-asawa, basta yung lalaki ang nagsumbong, sasabihin niya doon sa Rafi Tulfo in action na kahit gusto ng bata, kahit ano, anong mangyari, basta 7 years old na yung bata, pwede na siyang mamili.
08:33.2
And that only applies, mga kabatas natin, if the parties are married.
08:37.2
If the parties are not married.
08:38.2
If the parties are not married.
08:39.2
Eh, sole custody yung nanay.
08:42.2
Eh, paulit-ulit na naririnig ko sa kanya doon, nagmamagaling.
08:47.2
Doon, doon ako unang na bad trip.
08:50.2
Sabi niya, the journalist cannot be shielded from said criticism by the very nature of his profession.
08:58.2
Alam ko yung sasabihin nila dito.
09:00.2
Bakit journalist-journalist e Rafi Tulfo in action foundation dyan ang pinag-uusapan?
09:05.2
At saka copyright infringement yan.
09:07.2
Andami ng discussion, ho.
09:08.2
Sa copyright infringement sa taas.
09:11.2
Ang pinag-uusapan na ngayon, kung in-line ba yung ginagawa kong commentary doon sa profession ko bilang isang abogado.
09:23.2
So sinasabi ng korte dito na tama naman.
09:26.2
Kasi ikaw ay isang opisyal ng korte.
09:33.2
Dapat ganyan ang gawin mo.
09:36.2
Sabi niya, it is the public service nature of the program, not the profession of the program maker-host that opens up the limitation of the fair use on the copyright of the publisher at the very outset of the case as a function of freedom of speech and freedom of the press.
09:55.2
Public service pala eh.
09:57.2
Isipin niya mga kabatas natin, no?
09:59.2
Isang public service program na mahilig magkaso.
10:03.2
Isang public service program na mahilig mag-copyright strike.
10:08.2
Isang foundation na very hypocritical.
10:22.2
Parang palalabasin mo na mabait kang tao.
10:37.2
Atty. Ronnie Randolph Libayan is required by his profession as a lawyer to uphold the following provisions of the Code of Professional Responsibility and Accountability.
10:49.2
Nakalala ko tuloy dito yung ano?
10:52.2
Yung mga ampalaya.
10:55.2
Lagi nilang sinasabi na,
10:57.2
iya ang pagkocomment mo sa Rafi Tulfo in action.
11:00.2
Yan ay labag sa Code of Professional Responsibility and Accountability.
11:08.2
Tapos quote sila ng quote ng kung ano-ano.
11:12.2
Tingnan niyo ito.
11:14.2
Yung judge mismo.
11:16.2
Judge mismo ito ha!
11:18.2
Hindi basta-basta prosecutor.
11:22.2
Hindi basta-basta abogado.
11:27.2
Judge sa isang account.
11:30.2
hairs of the libel.
11:31.2
On the actual na kaso.
11:33.2
In other words, mga kabatas natin,
11:45.2
than anyone else.
11:47.2
than anything else.
11:49.2
Katulad ng mga sinasabi ko.
11:52.2
Disregard what I am saying.
11:54.2
Because I am not doing it in my professional capacity as a lawyer.
11:58.2
Kasi hindi naman ako talaga nasa korte.
12:03.3
Although still I have to act as a lawyer at all times,
12:08.1
follow, syempre, yung pagiging noble ng aking profession,
12:12.1
there is still a big distinction between me doing things in my social media,
12:20.8
and me doing things in court.
12:24.3
Pati piskal, ganyan din.
12:25.6
There is a huge distinction between their actions
12:30.2
when they are inside the court and when they vlog.
12:34.8
Ito, mga kabatas natin, yung judge, hindi siya nagbablog dito.
12:40.0
Yung judge dito, ginagawa niya yung kanyang tungkulin
12:43.2
bilang isang judge sa korte.
12:50.0
Which one bears more weight?
12:53.0
Ito bang gumagawa?
12:54.5
Ito bang gumagawa ng kanyang trabaho na pwede niyang ikatanggal
12:59.4
kung sakaling mali yung kanyang ginagawa?
13:02.6
O yung mga vloggers,
13:07.5
na nagbabahagi lang ng kanilang legal opinion dito sa social media?
13:19.1
Attorney Ronnie Randolph Billy Bayan is required.
13:22.6
Kailangan kong gawin ito.
13:24.5
By his profession as a lawyer to uphold the following provisions of the Code
13:31.4
of Professional Responsibility and Accountability.
13:35.6
Canon 2, Propriety, Responsible Use of Social Media.
13:43.6
A lawyer shall uphold the dignity of the legal profession
13:48.2
in all social media interactions in a manner that enhances
13:52.5
the people's confidence.
13:54.5
In the legal system as well as promote its responsible use.
14:00.6
Anong ginagawa ko?
14:02.4
Yung fact na lang mga kabatas natin
14:04.3
na I'm telling people about what Rafi Tulfo in action is doing wrong
14:10.3
is already promotion of the responsible use of social media.
14:22.2
Yung wag mong i-publicize yung away ng mga magkakamag-anak.
14:28.4
That's very irresponsible.
14:34.8
I enhance the people's confidence in the legal system.
14:37.9
Sinasabi ko sa tao, sumunod kayo sa due process.
14:40.6
Wag nyong sundin yung cut the process ni Rafi Tulfo.
14:44.7
Sumunod kayo sa justice system.
14:47.8
Wag kayong sumunod sa Tulfo brand of justice.
14:52.2
Interactions in a manner that enhances the people's confidence in the legal system.
15:04.4
Promote its responsible use.
15:06.3
Wag kayong mag-promote ng sugal.
15:09.7
Wag kayong mag-poverty porn.
15:12.9
Wag kayong mang-scam ng tao.
15:21.3
Promote its responsible use.
15:24.8
Anong sabi ng judge?
15:29.9
I am required as a lawyer to uphold the following provisions.
15:49.3
Sabi ni kayo, may backer kaya.
15:51.3
Ang judge na yan, attorney, kaya siya naging judge asking for not my friend.
15:56.3
Alam niyo yun kasi ang hindi ko rin gusto doon.
15:59.6
Yung pati yung mga judges, lalagyan mo yung shade, lalagyan mo ng shade yung kanilang pagka-appoint as a judge.
16:09.2
Kung hindi ka na-appoint as a judge,
16:13.1
wag mo namang sirain yung accomplishment ng ibang tao.
16:21.3
or may backer na politisya na malapit na presidente kaya mas malakas, mas madaling ma-appoint.
16:36.1
Pinaghihirapan ng mga judges, yung kanilang trabaho na yan.
16:40.7
Tapos sasabihin mo lang, or may backer.
16:47.6
Ikaw nga, hindi ka nga maka-judge-judge.
16:50.1
Tapos ngayon, I've stopped.
16:51.3
Kasi may backer nga dapat, di ba?
17:00.1
Alam mo, nakaka...
17:02.7
Parang sinabi pa yata ni Fabry doon, no?
17:06.6
Na parang sinabi niya na good,
17:11.2
tsaka may bad daw in a sense yung backer na yun.
17:14.4
May backer ka, may backer ka.
17:16.2
Yung fact pa lang na yung mga tao,
17:19.3
They interpreted it,
17:25.8
Kasi nga, backer.
17:33.0
how people use the word backer.
17:39.6
In the words of Rafi Tulfo,
17:44.2
were you born yesterday?
17:48.7
Were you born yesterday?
17:50.4
Alam naman natin,
17:51.2
di ba, may huhuliin sa kalsada.
17:54.8
Uy, huwag niyong huliin yan.
17:56.0
Malakas yung backer niyan.
18:01.8
Alam na natin kung ano yung ibig sabihin nun.
18:11.1
Bakit yan ang nakuhang ano?
18:14.8
Bakit yan ang nakuhang...
18:17.0
Anong tawag doon?
18:23.4
Malakas ang backer niyan eh.
18:25.5
So, pag sinabi bang malakas ang backer,
18:48.2
Huwag na tayo maglokohan.
18:51.2
Huwag na tayo maglokohan.
18:57.4
Iba naman yung tibacker.
19:12.8
may sasabihin siya na ako,
19:14.9
baka may umiyak lalo.
19:17.7
A lawyer shall have the duty
19:19.0
to understand the benefits,
19:20.9
and ethical implications
19:22.7
associated with the use of social media.
19:26.7
I always lecture about this, right?
19:30.8
Pako, huwag ka na mabatrip!
19:33.8
Huwag ka na mabatrip.
19:35.3
Sisig lang katapat niyan.
19:44.2
Lawyers have the duty to understand
19:46.3
the benefits, risks, and ethical implications
19:49.2
associated with the use of social media.
19:52.1
Sinasabi lang sa akin,
19:53.4
na parang, oh, hindi mo
19:55.7
ginagamit ethically yung social media.
19:59.4
Pagtitignan niya din, mga kabatas natin.
20:01.7
Ang nagsasabi lang naman sa akin ng ganun,
20:04.5
eh yung mga kampon ni Rafi Tulfo.
20:06.9
Kampon ng Rafi Tulfo in action.
20:11.5
Bakit iba yung sinasabi ni Judge?
20:14.8
Iba yung sinasabi ng ibang tao?
20:17.3
Iba yung sinasabi ng ibang lawyer?
20:19.2
Pag hindi kampon ni Rafi Tulfo,
20:26.4
Section 37, online posts.
20:29.5
A lawyer shall ensure that his or her online posts,
20:32.2
whether made in public or restricted privacy,
20:34.8
or restricted privacy setting that still upholds,
20:38.3
that still holds an audience,
20:40.3
uphold the dignity of the legal profession
20:42.8
and shield it from disrepute,
20:46.8
as well as maintain respect for the law.
20:49.2
At ang mga kabatas natin,
20:50.1
ngayon din akong narinig na abogado na sinabi na sobrang bagal po
21:05.8
ng ating justice system.
21:10.1
Huwag ho kayong mag-file ng kaso sa korte
21:13.1
pag ang kalaban niyo ay local government.
21:17.4
Kasi po ang local government,
21:21.5
Ang nagpapahiram ng building sa Justice Hall
21:26.6
Kaya pag mapapansin nyo po yung ating City Hall at Justice Hall ay nasa iisang building
21:30.8
Online posts uphold the dignity of the legal profession and shield it from disrepute
21:39.1
Napakabagal ng ating justice system
21:42.8
Pag sinabi mo ba yun, you are shielding it from disrepute
21:49.6
Disrepute or you are opening it
21:57.5
By people who will cast disrepute to the justice system
22:06.0
Maintain respect for the law
22:12.8
Opo sir, let's just cut the process
22:25.3
Sabi ni Knowledge
22:26.2
Miriam Defensor Santiago must be turning endlessly on her grave with what's happening to the Senate now
22:37.8
Sa totoo lang, sinabi ko na sa livestream ko to
22:40.9
Nung nakita ko yung mga moves ni Fiscal
22:42.7
EJ, medyo na-disappoint ako sa law profession
22:46.5
Kapapanood nyo kasi dyan
22:47.6
Hindi, hindi, hindi
22:58.1
We have to accept that fact
23:03.8
In fairness to them
23:05.9
Na-disappoint yata sa lahat
23:11.1
Lahat ng bayaran sa kanila naman
23:12.0
Lahat ng bayaran sa kanila naman
23:12.1
Lahat ng bayaran sa kanila naman
23:12.7
Na-disappoint sa law profession dahil sa akin
23:17.7
Lahat ng nabayaran
23:18.8
Lahat ng kasali sa payroll sa kanila
23:23.9
Na-disappoint sa law profession
23:32.1
Yun lang naman sasabi nila sa'yo
23:33.5
Ganyan din naman siya
23:36.3
Ganyan din naman si Atty. Libayan
23:38.4
Pero ako kasi mga kamatas natin
23:47.0
Positive feedback from
23:49.1
The legal profession
23:50.6
From the legal community
23:51.8
What is more positive
23:55.7
Of a positive feedback
24:10.8
Raffi Tulfo versus PAO
24:14.4
Naging famous ako sa PAO
24:17.7
Marami ako naging friend na PAO
24:24.9
Hi po sa inyo ma'am
24:30.3
Because of course
24:35.2
Nanakwento ko ba sa inyo
24:39.2
Na tumawag sa akin
24:40.5
Si Atty. Acosta nun
24:43.1
Dumaan pa sa marami
24:46.0
Tumawag siya kay gantor
24:48.4
Tumawag siya kay ganyan
24:49.7
Tumawag siya kay ganyan
24:51.9
Nakausap niya ako
25:00.2
What are we doing?
25:03.1
What are we doing?
25:17.3
Yung pagiging isang public attorney
25:23.5
That is a legal profession
25:27.3
I have to protect it
25:31.8
From invento time ni Raffi Tulfo
25:41.5
Umiiyak ka na yata Kayo eh
25:43.1
Huwag kang magalala
25:47.6
Hindi ang issue kung may hina or hindi eh
25:50.9
More on principles
25:51.9
On playing fair and engaging in good faith
25:54.2
Faith na disappoint ako
25:55.9
Actually I was also disappointed
25:57.9
Sinabi ko naman sa inyo eh
26:00.5
Gumanon ako doon sa
26:01.7
Yung opening pa lang niya
26:07.4
Doon sawag na natin yung pag-usapan na
26:12.1
I was disappointed
26:14.1
I was expecting more
26:18.5
All I got was that
26:21.1
Akala nila mapapahiya nila ako
26:25.4
Napahiya nila ako
26:29.8
Saka sa kanila rin
26:30.8
Eh wala naman ako may papanalo sa kanila eh
26:40.3
Disappointed kasi di na-appoint
26:42.5
Eh baka walang backer kasi
26:50.9
Legal Information
26:54.0
Pursuant to a lawyer's duty to society and the legal profession
26:58.4
A lawyer may provide general legal information
27:01.9
That's why I'm telling you always
27:07.4
We treat them hypothetically
27:11.3
Yung mga pinag-uusapan natin
27:12.8
We presume everyone as innocent until proven guilty
27:16.2
Then I provide general legal information
27:21.5
Kung ganyan yung nangyari
27:27.3
Including in answer to questions asked
27:31.8
Diba ang daming nagtatanong dito?
27:42.1
Huwag ganyan no nonsense
27:45.4
Anong ginagawa mo dyan?
27:50.1
Alam nyo kasi mga kapatid natin
27:54.9
Whenever things like this happen
27:56.3
People pull strings
27:59.4
Ang daming nangyayari
28:04.6
Ngayon ang daming nangyayari
28:09.2
Ang daming nangyayari
28:10.2
Ang daming nangyayari
28:10.2
Ang daming nangyayari
28:10.2
Ang daming nangyayari
28:10.3
Ang daming nangyayari
28:10.3
Ang daming nangyayari
28:10.3
Ang daming nangyayari ngayon
28:11.0
And I'll tell you eventually
28:13.2
I'll tell you eventually
28:15.3
After this 30 to 0
28:17.9
Ang daming nangyayari
28:19.0
Ang daming developments dun sa mga ibang kaso
28:23.9
Some good, some bad
28:29.4
Siyempre mga kapatid natin
28:31.6
Ang sinasabi ko lang mga kapatid natin
28:34.9
Siyempre it depends on the perspective
28:42.5
Ewan ko kung magpa-file ulit sila ng kaso
28:44.7
But I think after this one
28:49.0
I think it will be a stupid choice
28:50.6
To be filing more cases
28:52.1
Pero it's up to you
29:00.9
Kasi nga mga kapatid natin
29:05.6
Imagine the time and the resources
29:07.9
That you took away from the case
29:10.1
Because of filing this
29:13.0
Sabi sa desisyon yun na
29:30.6
Youtube, Facebook
00:00.0
30:10.080 --> 30:11.720
30:16.9
Sabi ni Esperneto
30:19.7
Anyway mga kapatid natin
30:27.8
Lipat tayo sa kabila
30:28.8
I think we can finish this na
30:31.1
Ay hindi pa siguro
30:33.3
Pero we're almost done
30:34.9
Makikita niyo yung
30:36.5
May sobrang juicy dito mga kapatid natin
30:39.6
Maraming salamat po
30:40.8
At syempre tulad na lang yung sinasabi
30:42.1
Matulog po tayo ng mahimbing
30:43.8
Na yung natutulog ng mahimbing
30:44.8
Siya yung laging panalo
